Below is the 2008 – 2009 men’s college squash All-Liberty League team:
- Hameed Ahmed (Rochester)
- Jim Bristow (Rochester)
- Alex Dodge (St. Lawrence)
- Matt Domenick (Rochester)
- Ben Fischer (Rochester)
- Cale Forgues (Hobart)
- Will Newnham (Rochester)
- Nick Pearson (St. Lawrence)
- Fred Reid (Rochester)
Below are the honorable mentions:
- Joe Chapman (Rochester)
- Peter Hansen (Hobart)
- Kevin Kent (Hobart)
- Thomas Kraft (St. Lawrence)
- Adam Perkiomaki (Rochester)
- Scott Redpath (St. Lawrence)
- Tyler Stout (St. Lawrence)